Can I Lose Maintenance and Cure If I Didn’t Disclose a Prior Injury?

McCorpen Defense

Possibly, but only in limited situations. Under the McCorpen defense, an employer can deny maintenance and cure if you intentionally hid a medical condition it asked about, the condition mattered to the hiring decision, and it is linked to your new injury. The employer must prove all three, and it does not automatically end your Jones Act claim.

Many seamen are hired after filling out a medical questionnaire or taking a physical exam. Later, after a real injury, the employer pulls out that paperwork and points to an old back strain, a past surgery, or a prior claim you did not list. Then the maintenance and cure checks stop.

If that sounds familiar, do not assume you are out of options. A maintenance and cure denied because of a prior injury is not always legal, and the employer carries a heavy burden to justify it. Below, we will explain how the McCorpen defense works, when it applies, and what injured seamen can do about it. It is part of how we approach admiralty and maritime injury law for workers along the Gulf Coast.

What Is the McCorpen Defense in a Maintenance and Cure Case?

The McCorpen defense comes from a 1968 federal appeals court decision, McCorpen v. Central Gulf Steamship Corp. The court held that a seaman can lose the right to maintenance and cure if he knowingly hides a prior medical condition from the employer. Courts along the Gulf Coast still apply this rule today.

Maintenance and cure normally applies no matter who caused the accident. Maintenance is a daily amount for food and lodging, and cure is payment for reasonable medical care. The McCorpen defense is one of the few ways an employer can avoid that duty.

It is also a narrow defense. Courts view maintenance and cure as a protection for seamen, and doubts are generally resolved in the worker’s favor. An employer cannot use the defense just because you had an old injury. It has to prove specific facts.

What Does the Employer Have to Prove?

The employer must establish all three of the following:

  • Concealment. You intentionally misrepresented or failed to disclose medical information on a pre-employment form, interview, or exam. In some cases, courts have found this element met when a seaman gave a wrong answer to a clear question, even without proof that he meant to deceive anyone.
  • Materiality. The hidden information mattered to the decision to hire you. In practice, that means the employer would likely have not hired you, or would have treated you differently, had it known.
  • Connection. There is a causal link between the condition you did not disclose and the injury you are now claiming.

If the employer cannot prove any one of these, the defense should fail. The third element is often where these cases are won, because a prior injury to one part of the body does not necessarily connect to a new injury somewhere else.

How Do Courts Treat Common Situations?

Every case turns on its own facts, but the table below shows how the three elements often play out.

Situation Does the defense likely apply? Why
The employer never asked about medical history Unlikely Without a question, there is usually nothing to conceal
The form asked about back problems, and you answered “no” despite a prior back surgery More likely A clear question, a wrong answer, and possibly a link to a new back injury
The form asked about the last five years, and your injury was ten years ago Unlikely The old condition fell outside what the employer asked about
You did not know you had a condition Unlikely Courts generally look for knowing concealment
You disclosed the condition and were hired anyway Unlikely Nothing was hidden
You hid a prior knee injury, but your new injury is to your shoulder Unlikely There may be no connection between the two

These are general illustrations, not predictions. Courts look closely at the exact wording of the questions and the answers given.

Does Hiding a Prior Injury End Your Whole Case?

No. This is one of the most important points for injured seamen to understand. The McCorpen defense goes to maintenance and cure. It does not automatically defeat a Jones Act negligence claim or an unseaworthiness claim for the same accident.

If your employer’s negligence or an unsafe vessel helped cause your injury, you may still be able to seek damages for lost earning capacity, future medical care, and pain and suffering. A court may consider your nondisclosure when assigning fault, which could reduce an award, but it is not the same as barring the claim. Our article on common legal challenges seamen face after an injury covers other defenses employers raise.

A prior condition also does not mean you cannot recover for a Jones Act pre-existing injury that was made worse on the job. If work on the vessel aggravated an earlier problem, that aggravation can be part of your claim.

What Should You Do If Your Employer Raises the Defense?

If an employer or insurer says you concealed a medical condition, the steps you take next matter.

  1. Do not sign anything yet. A release or statement can limit your rights.
  2. Ask for the paperwork. Request copies of the questionnaire, exam forms, and anything else you completed at hiring.
  3. Gather your own medical history. Prior records can show what the condition really was, how long ago it happened, and whether it relates to your new injury.
  4. Keep getting treatment. Do not stop seeing your doctors because benefits were cut off.
  5. Write down what happened at hiring. Note who asked the questions, how they were worded, and what you were told.
  6. Talk to a maritime lawyer early. The employer must prove its defense, and a lawyer can test whether it can.

If benefits stopped without a good reason, there may be remedies. We explain more in our article on what happens when an employer stops maintenance and cure.

Tips for Medical Questionnaires in Maritime Jobs

If you are applying for a vessel job now, a few habits can prevent trouble later:

  • Read each question carefully and answer exactly what it asks.
  • If you are unsure whether something counts, disclose it or ask for clarification.
  • Keep a copy of every form you sign.
  • Do not guess. If you do not remember a date, say so.

Answering honestly protects both your job and your future benefits.

Talk to a Maritime Lawyer About Your Maintenance and Cure Claim

Fuquay Law Firm has represented injured deckhands, captains, and other maritime workers along the Gulf Coast for more than 30 years. If your employer denied maintenance and cure because of a prior injury, we can review your hiring paperwork and medical records, explain your options, and help you decide what to do next.

Call (251) 473-4443 or request a free consultation. You can also find our Mobile office on Google Maps at 660 Springhill Ave.

Frequently Asked Questions

What if I forgot about an old injury when I filled out the form?

Forgetting is different from hiding. Courts generally look for knowing concealment, so an honest mistake about a minor or distant condition may not support the defense. The details matter, so have a lawyer review your situation.

Does the employer have to prove I lied on purpose?

The employer must prove intentional concealment, but courts have sometimes found this element satisfied when a seaman failed to answer a clear question accurately, even without proof of a plan to deceive. This is a fact-heavy issue that varies by case.

What if my old injury was to a different body part?

That can help you. The employer must show a causal link between the concealed condition and your new injury. If they involve different parts of the body, the connection may be hard to prove.

Does the defense apply if I was never asked about my medical history?

Generally, the defense depends on the employer asking for medical information. If no questionnaire, exam, or interview covered your history, there may be nothing to conceal. Your employer may still argue otherwise, so keep any hiring records.

Can I still file a Jones Act claim if maintenance and cure is denied?

Yes, in many cases. The McCorpen defense targets maintenance and cure. A Jones Act negligence claim or an unseaworthiness claim depends on different facts, and a denial of maintenance and cure does not automatically end them.

My employer stopped paying after raising a pre-existing condition. Is that legal?

It depends on whether the employer can prove the defense. If the cutoff was unreasonable or made in bad faith, the law may allow additional remedies. Speak with a maritime attorney quickly, because a stop in benefits can create financial hardship.

Should I hire a lawyer if my employer raises a prior injury?

It is worth a conversation. These cases depend on the exact wording of forms, your medical history, and how the injuries connect. A lawyer can review the paperwork and tell you whether the employer’s position holds up.

Related Articles

Table of Contents